Monday, 8 April 2013
Thursday, 7 February 2013
FINAL ADVICE
You now have everything I could possibly give you (short of writing the assignment for you!)
Remember, as a high ability class, a certain degree of the preparation comes from you. You should have been spending time re-reading the key scenes, rewatching the film, and finding differences/similarities between the two representations of Lady Macbeth.
High ability students such as yourselves should be able to have a good go at a task like this even without any of the notes or film analysis sheets that I have given you, so you are more than prepared.
Don't stress.
This assignment is worth 12% of your English Literature GCSE - just to put things into perspective. The exam you sat in the summer was worth 50%!!!!
Well done to everybody who came back for over an hour after school today to work on notes. You are all stars.
For those who couldn't make it, here is what we discussed.
Intro - Talk about how things have changed between 1606-2006 - Attitudes towards women - The rise of suffrage - Women in 1606 not even allowed to act - the confines of theatres - modern day effects etc.
Talk about anything that you see as being relevant to the different portrayal of LM. Talk about mental illness and how that is viewed as different now.
Then - Go on to focussing on your set scenes in turn. Try to write about 5 PEE paragraphs for each scene. The mark scheme says that you have to comment on:
LANGUAGE - What LM and other characters say, and how this is different
FORM - What sort of language they use/formality/power/who speaks most
STRUCTURE - How the play fits together, which bits are added, taken out etc.
Now not all of your points will fit into LANGAUGE, FORM or STRUCTURE. That is ok, but just make sure you comment on all of them quite a lot in your essay. FOCUS ON LANGAUGE. IT IS VERY IMPORTANT YOU INCLUDE LOTS OF QUOTES (But you knew that already!)
As for timings, you have 2 hours in total to do this, meaning it will probably be spread across 3 lessons.
For tomorrow's lesson simply focus on the intro and the first 2 set scenes. If you get on to commenting on Act 5 scene 1, you are rushing it - so spend time writing some fantastic notes for this over the weekend.
Now - over to you. Do your best and don't stress :)
NW
Film Analysis Act 5 Sc 1
Act 5 Scene 1
1:14:50
Lady Macbeth is shown wide eyed and smiling brightly as she
reminisces about her baby. She is wearing very little make-up and looks natural
(which might make her look less manipulative and more trustworthy/pitiful).
When talking about the procedure in the hospital, she says ‘They
cut me open.’ This generates sympathy for LM, but also puts into our minds the
idea that she has been hurt before. This is not like in the original script at
all where LM merely talks about her crimes as she is sleep walking.
1:15:18 “Some night Joe and I sat looking at him in his
little box.” This adds a totally human element to the two characters. The fact
she refers to them by their first names, and the scenario we imagine them in,
looking after their sick child, means we can feel nothing but sympathy for them
as a couple.
In a modern setting, this couple would have received counselling
for their grief – not like in the original script where the audience would not
find sympathy in their hearts at all.
“…all hooked up with tubes.” LM begins to cry at the memory
of her trauma, evoking more sympathy.
“We didn’t go to sleep.” – an interesting comparison to the
original text. In the original text LM is sleep walking in this scene. Here,
she is merely dillusional and thinking back to this sad time when she could not
sleep. Sleep is used as a powerful image here to show her mental state.
1:15:30 – “I held him once” – Sympathy for LM again.
1:15:45 – Begins to smile again when she says “he put his
little mouth to me” – interestingly, LM looks at her happiest when she is
reminiscing about being a mother, a role which (in this version) she has been
robbed of. Little is made of her role as a mother in the original.
1:15:50 – “and then he died” – followed by a very
long/dramatic pause to allow us to feel sympathy for the character.
1:16:00 – “The size of the coffin: It was so small, it made
me laugh.” shows us the deteriorated mental state of LM.
All this time, the director has chosen to have LM deliver
this monologue whilst the camera angle is panned in close to her face which
makes the scene seem very personal and upsetting. At this stage, the camera
pans out, and we realise that LM is actually standing at the front of the
restaurant, again emphasising her mental state.
The sympathetic and confused reactions of the onlooking
customers signifies the sympathy they feel for her loss/worry (despite the fact
that we know she is a criminal) – totally different to original.
Onlookers are blurred to signify the fact that LM has lost
contact now with the outside world and is completely introverted.
Camera pans out to show a distant and lonely shot of LM.
Film Analysis of the interim scenes...
These parts do not correspond to our key scenes, but may be worth mentioning anyway...
Doesn’t apply to any set scene but is relevant for the
character of LM
47:40 – LM leads police press conference.
52:40 LM sings ‘Oh Lord won’t you buy me a Mercedes Benz’.
Shows how materialistic she is.
53:00 – 1:04:00 – Macbeth gradually becomes more power
hungry and starts showing signs of going a bit mad. He also confesses to taking
drugs and tells ‘Banquo’ ‘I’m just a bit wired’ when he begins to act strange.
1:08:44 – M goes crazy at the feast. He says to LM ‘Why
won’t you look at me? You look at yourself in the mirror, but you won’t look at
me.’ ‘Am I worse than you?’
It also becomes obvious that LM has been coaching him what
to say.
1:09:00 – LM remains calm as M has a breakdown
1:10:20 – LM partly blames M for the breakdown of the
relationship ‘ We were together once but then you stopped talking to me.’
Implies that the murder hasn’t bothered her, but the fact that he is shutting
her out is.
1:10:45 – LM is watched by M in the shower. He sees her
covered in blood. Image of blame from director.
1:12:00 - LM starts
to look bothered/out of control when the customers leave the restaurant. Ie,
when the restaurant gets out of control.
Film Analysis Act 1 Scene 7
Act 1 Scene 7
30:30 – She is shown as caring towards M, bandaging his
hands and looking after him.
30:46 – “You’ve done this. You’re a knifeman Joe, you know
how it feels.”
M protests, but LM replies with “It’s all set up. You do
this, and we win EVERYTHING.” There is no emphasis on fate. She very much sees
this now as ‘winning’.
31:00 – Talks about her baby. I know how it feels to have a
baby feed at my breast’ ‘There was a smile wasn’t there?’ Makes us feel sorry
for her. They are portrayed as a struggling young family.
Macbeth seems ‘persuaded’ by her crying over the baby. After
this, the scene cuts.
33:00 – ‘IN another life I’d make a pass at you’ ‘In another
life I’ll let you’. Implies that she uses sex to influence Duncan . Also, it could be implied that there
is more to their relationship than friendship. Not something we see in the
original.
‘Bewitching woman.’ Duncan .
‘Bewitching’ is when someone has the ability to influence you in an almost
supernatural way. It is an interesting comparison. In the original text, LM is
‘in league’ with evil spirits. In this version, she ‘bewitches him’ him
sex/flirting.
Because of Duncan ’s
attempts to flirt with LM, the audience sees him more as ‘deserving’ of his
death. Perhaps this makes us more sympathetic towards LM/M?
35:00 LM summons M to the murder by ringing him on his
phone. This replaces the ‘bell’ which we see in the original text. Giving LM
more control over the situation.
36:15 LM goes to great lengths to ‘set up’ the foreign dish
washers so that it will look like they have killed Duncan . This shows huge plotting on the part
of LM. She had to have all of this in place well in advance.
38:00 M’s famous soliloquy where he considers whether or not
he should be doing what he is doing does not feature in this film. This means
that LM is shown as being far less outwardly persuasive towards M.
In the original script, we do not see/witness the murder so
this whole scene gives us a different perspective on the characters involved
39:00-41:00 – Crucially, M decides he can not go back in to Duncan ’s room to finish
the job. LM actually goes in and takes part in the crime, meaning that she is
portrayed as being far more involved/to blame than in the original script.
41:40 – M says that the police will know that the second
knife ‘didn’t go into’ Duncan .
At which point LM gives him a knowing look and says ‘Remember, we’re in this
together.’ She is portrayed as being more evil, plotting and calculating here
than the original LM. She has actually gone into Duncan ’s room and stabbed the corpse to make
it look more convincing.
42:00 She is shown to be totally psychopathic when she says
‘It was easier for me’ and smiles/kisses M.
Film analysis - Act 1 Sc 5
This is my analysis of the section of the film which roughly corresponds to Act1 Sc5
You have this already - and it does not exactly correspond...
You have this already - and it does not exactly correspond...
Act 1 Scene 5
3:30 – 4:00 – Relationship between M and LM
10:15 – 11:00 – M is annoyed by Duncan even before LM’s intervention
11:00 – 11:30 – Duncan
flirts with LM implying a flirty relationship.
14:00 – “Michelin stars” – M looks bothered and looks to LM
for comfort. This is before she even knows about the predicition.
15:50 – Duncan
‘predicts’ his own demise by announcing he will stay in the guest room and
jokes that ‘he won’t see anything of the following day’. LM looks
disapprovingly.
16:30 – ‘Run over by a bus’ – LM appears in the doorway to
wintess Duncan ’s
comment that if he goes under a bus, the restaurant will be M’s. At this point,
LM still hasn’t said anything but her facial expressions show that she is
thinking about the matter.
17:15 M and LM are both equally annoyed about the restaurant
going to Duncan ’s
son. ‘He is more like a hairdresser than a chef’ LM ‘Everything we’ve built is
gonna go to a hairdresser’ M
‘I hate the injustice’.
LM reminds him that Duncan
will get all the glory and asks ‘Are your going to let that go?’
She flirs with him and rubs noses as she persuades him – use
of sex.
Both are drunk (drinking from hipflask)
19:00 Macbeth seems happy with his working conditions. LM
tells him that Duncan
is paying him in ‘charm and blarney’. She tells him to his face that he is ‘too
full of the milk of human kindness’ to wind him up. ‘What kind of man is it?’
Always whispers in his ear.
19:37 – M challenges her physically and goes to pull away,
but she seduces him.
20:00 – LM implies to M that they should kill him. M never
actually speaks. It is assumed they both know what she means.
21:15 – forces Macbeth to sack workers even though he does
not want to. Shows power
25:40 – She is very nice to Duncan and acts like she is really supportive
of him.
28:00-30:00 LM makes M more angry by sending Duncan out to meet guests
when the food is ready to go. She engineers a reason for M to dislike Duncan . Not what she does
in original.
Wednesday, 6 February 2013
Note writing session tomorrow after school
Self explanatory really! I will stay behind after school in L25 to help with pointing you in the right direction with your notes, for anyone who is struggling to get started.
Try and let me know during the day, and pass the message on.
NW
Try and let me know during the day, and pass the message on.
NW
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)